• Home
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Real Estate
    • Q&A
    • Business Profiles
    • Networking
    • Public Record
    • Opinion
      • Our View
  • Real Estate & Construction
    • Latest News
    • Top Properties
    • Building Permits
    • Building Tri-Cities
  • Special Publications
    • Book of Lists
    • Best Places to Work
    • People of Influence
    • Young Professionals
    • Hanford
    • Energy
    • Focus: Agriculture + Viticulture
    • Focus: Construction + Real Estate
  • E-Edition
  • Calendar
    • Calendar
    • Submit an Event
  • Journal Events
    • Senior Times Expo
    • Young Professionals
      • Sponsor Young Professionals
    • Best Places to Work
      • Sponsor BPTW
    • People of Influence
      • Sponsor People of Influence
  • Senior Times
    • About Senior Times
    • Read Senior Times Stories
    • Senior Times Expo
    • Obituaries and Death Notices
Home » Oil and mineral rights difficult to profit from, complicate estate planning

Oil and mineral rights difficult to profit from, complicate estate planning

May 14, 2020
Guest Contributor

Property rights are often considered a “bundle of sticks” where a person can own varying interests in land.

The person can own the entire bundle—called “fee simple.”

Or a person can own distinct and specific interests in a piece of property. One form of ownership is the ownership of only the oil and mineral rights found in or under a piece of land.

This “asset” is typical of states such as North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas and Wyoming, among others.

Though less common here in the Pacific Northwest, many individuals in all parts of the county own oil and mineral rights. They might acquire them on their own or they might acquire ownership through inheritance or from their family members.

The ownership of this asset presents complexities that both potential and existing owners should understand.

Unlike the ownership of a stock or bond, the ownership of oil and mineral rights is the ownership of real property —i.e., land.

That means that the ownership of oil and mineral rights will subject that asset to probate in the state where the right exists.

Most people try to limit the reach and expense of probate. The ownership of oil and mineral rights increases the likelihood of multiple probates and the associated expenses.

Owners should consider this when putting together their estate plan by utilizing specific tools to deal with the assets. It might be a living trust that holds solely the oil and mineral rights. It might be a transfer on death deed.

It might be a gift of the asset prior to death. In any event the continued ownership adds complexity to the estate plan, the resulting probate and the fractionalization of ownership of the asset as it is split among heirs.

The returns from the ownership of oil and mineral and gas interests typically come from the lease of those interests to companies trying to extract the resources. The lease payments are subject the actual content of the land, the ability of the company to extract the contents and the global market for the oil, minerals or other valuable resources.

The asset is not readily marketable. That is, it is not easy to sell.

If you want to sell your house or land, it is easy to contact a local Realtor and get it listed on the multiple listing service immediately.

And the proposed selling price is relatively easy to ascertain based on the mountains of available data. Selling stocks, bonds and mutual funds is even easier. The sale price is published every second (for stocks) on the stock exchanges, and the sale can happen in less than a second with the click of a button.

In contrast, the value of oil and mineral rights can be difficult to ascertain. It might require the use of an appraiser local to the area and specializing in those rights. Then, the sale of the asset does not occur on any publicly available market like houses and stocks do, complicating efforts to sell.

It is rare that a person owns oil and mineral rights sufficient to deal directly with a major gas or oil or mining company.

Rather, most people own a small piece (or a fraction of a small piece) of the total area that a big company might be interested in leasing. This means that to enter a successful leasing arrangement, the owner of the oil and mineral rights needs other owners to be committed to the leasing arrangement and its terms.

This weakens each individual owner’s position.

In effect, it makes the owner a minority interest owner because his or her decisions can rarely be made in isolation.

Notably, this column avoids the discussion of the actual returns obtained from oil and mineral rights leases.

They may be quite lucrative. Or they might be abysmal.

To determine the value of lease terms, it is essential to know the value of selling the asset. If you sold the asset and invested elsewhere, could you beat the lease terms you are contemplating receiving?

And, because a valuation is so difficult and there is no broad market for selling, it is difficult to glean the information necessary to determine if the lease payments are good.

And the complexities of ownership outlined in this column should be considered along with the returns to really determine whether it is a good investment. All things being equal, perhaps a simpler asset is preferable to one that is complex.

Beau Ruff, a licensed attorney, is the director of planning at Cornerstone Wealth Strategies, a full-service independent investment management and financial planning firm in Kennewick.

    Local News Environment
    KEYWORDS may 2020
    Guest contributor 1 300x300
    Guest Contributor

    Ag industry tries to find footing in changing world

    More from this author
    Free Email Updates

    Daily and Monthly News

    Sign up now!

    Featured Poll

    How does summer affect your business in the Tri-Cities?

    Popular Articles

    • Blue bridge work
      By Senior Times

      Pasco, Kennewick ranked among ‘best places’ on national lists

    • Surfthru1
      By Building Tri-Cities advertising

      Surf Thru Express Car Wash

    • Peanuspark1
      By TCAJOB Staff

      Pasco sets park planning meetings

    • Clearwaterlofts1
      By Building Tri-Cities advertising

      Clearwater Lofts

    • Top properties
      By TCAJOB Staff

      Top Properties – June 2025

    • News Content
      • Latest news
      • Real Estate & Construction
      • Public records
      • Special publications
      • Senior Times
    • Customer Service
      • Our Readers
      • Subscriptions
      • Advertise
      • Editorial calendar
      • Media Kit
    • Connect With Us
      • Submit news
      • Submit an event
      • E-newsletters
      • E-Edition
      • Contact
    • Learn More
      • About Us
      • Our Events
      • FAQs
      • Privacy Policy
      • Spokane Journal of Business

    Mailing Address: 8656 W. Gage Blvd., Ste. C303  Kennewick, WA 99336 USA

    MCM_Horiz.png

    All content copyright © 2025 Mid-Columbia Media Inc. All rights reserved.
    No reproduction, transmission or display is permitted without the written permissions of Mid-Columbia Media Inc.

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing